Hello, sh.itjust.works community. I am curious what you think about ClubsAll, and whether you think we should stay federated with them. A few other Lemmy instances have recently defederated so this seems like a timely topic for discussion.
In short, ClubsAll is an ActivityPub-compatible Reddit clone. The site currently has one-way federation with no attribution: ClubsAll pulls content from Lemmy and displays it as local ClubsAll content. For example, you can visit https://clubsall.com/c/196 and there is no indication that the content is from https://lemmy.blahaj.zone/c/196.
Here are relevant posts with more information and context:
- General discussion: Let’s talk about ClubsAll (the ClubsAll founder left comments in this post)
- Recent update to that general discussion: As a reminder, ClubsAll is still showing all of Lemmy’s content without federating back
In the first post the ClubsAll founder commented that they plan to eventually have two-way federation, and to make the project open source. Whether those things actually happens is anyone’s guess.
What do you think?
I will leave my personal opinions down here in the comments.
On one hand, no harm is being done. It’s possible this is a temporary situation due to ClubsAll being young and in development. Also, all our data on Lemmy is public anyway; we cannot stop others from scraping it.
On the other hand, on principle I don’t like one-way interaction and the way ClubsAll presents Lemmy content as their own. It feels deceptive. Defederation would be a symbolic way to protest that behavior.
I am torn. At the moment I am slightly in favor of defederation.
I agree with this opinion. Do what you gotta do.
I’ve been around the block a few times, so maybe I’m just jaded.
My take is that it’s a proprietary platform, siphoning user data/content to redisplay and monetize.
Additionally, my gut feeling is that they don’t care about the community at all, and are just trying to leverage it to make money. They want to be the next reddit, and think the fediverse is their ticket. And I don’t think anything I’ve seen so far indicates otherwise.
We block Threads, and I think we should block this, too, immediately. If, in the future, the situation changes and they actually “give and take” rather than just “take” , then it should be simple enough to refederate.
My 2c.
If I wanted to start another Reddit, this is what I would do. Hell, siphoning content from Reddit is still done in many places on Lemmy to stock the pond. In this case, we have the opportunity to stop it before a competing platform takes off. If they’re not going to play by the rules of federation, they don’t deserve the bounty.
How about giving some leeway if they have indicated the intent to fully federate? Say, if they don’t support bidirectional federation with 6 months (?), they will be defederated provisionally until they do. That way, we’re still taking their declared intent in good faith, but not being a pushover.
I like this. I will put a reminder on my calendar to check on ClubsAll in a few months. If more users complain about it then we can reconsider the approach.
I like this solution.
Seems reasonable. I don’t have any technical complaint with what they’re doing, but it feels icky as long as there’s no attribution.
That seems fair.
One issue with the lack of attribution with canonical tags is it could break SEO, if that matters to you.
I don’t want to strangle anyone’s project in the crib, but it needs post attribution at the very least. I can understand it being a project in the early stages, but it’s not hard to include info on the source of the posts.
However, if they had that but weren’t yet open source and had only one-way federation, I would be open to giving them a date to hit for those. I don’t like the idea of one-way federation, nor of federation with a closed-source project, but to take the dev at face value and allow them a time frame of 6 months or so to clear it up would be acceptable.
All that being said, as it stands now I would vote to defederate due to the lack of attribution. It is the very least that could be done and shouldn’t be hard to implement.
Personally, I’m not too opposed to one-way federation, at least for the moment. They’re not a large platform, nor particularly competitve with the more open Fediverse (for the moment). The lack of attribution on the other hand, is iffy, both in terms of giving OC creators proper attribution for their work, and in terms of reducing misinformation (IE showing .ml posts as standard news posts).
All that said, I don’t think its a large enough issue to be concerned about for now. Give it like 3-6 months and see if things have changed (or if the problem has disappeared). This isn’t like Threads where we have to worry about a billion dollar Embrace Extend Extinguish campaign. Who knows, if we’re esspecially lucky, the site might grow into a better Fediverse alternative to Lemmy, or will grow and die in a way that sends positive users our way - something that would greatly benifit the Fediverse in it’s current state.
ClubsAll is an ActivityPub-compatible Reddit clone.
Uh… I thought that’s what I’m on right now